Buy or rent calculator
Is it better to buy or to rent?
Compare the cost of owning a home with renting a like one. The chart shows what each side would hold if the home were sold at the end of each year.
Buy or rent calculatorPropInsights.sg
Owning stays ahead from
Good:
After every cost and the return your deposit could have earned.
Owning stays ahead from: Year 4. After every cost and the return your deposit could have earned.
Cash at the start
S$422,600
Down payment S$375,000 + stamp duty S$44,600 + legal S$3,000
Owning, per month (year 1)
S$4,405
Interest, upkeep, tax and lost return on the deposit
Renting, per month (year 1)
S$4,000
S$, nominal. Owning is net of selling costs, SSD and the loan.
Owning: home sale proceeds plus savingsRenting: deposit and savings invested
Hover or use the arrow keys to read a value.
Chart data as a table
| Owning: home sale proceeds plus savings | Renting: deposit and savings invested | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | S$166,993 | S$452,787 |
| 2 | S$294,408 | S$482,914 |
| 3 | S$425,137 | S$517,134 |
| 4 | S$561,815 | S$551,437 |
| 5 | S$704,679 | S$585,787 |
| 6 | S$782,337 | S$620,145 |
| 7 | S$862,391 | S$654,469 |
| 8 | S$944,914 | S$688,714 |
| 9 | S$1,029,982 | S$722,832 |
| 10 | S$1,117,675 | S$756,772 |
| 11 | S$1,208,073 | S$790,480 |
| 12 | S$1,301,260 | S$823,896 |
| 13 | S$1,397,322 | S$856,959 |
| 14 | S$1,497,983 | S$891,238 |
| 15 | S$1,603,561 | S$926,887 |
| 16 | S$1,714,279 | S$963,963 |
| 17 | S$1,830,289 | S$1,002,521 |
| 18 | S$1,951,821 | S$1,042,622 |
| 19 | S$2,079,122 | S$1,084,327 |
| 20 | S$2,212,451 | S$1,127,700 |
| 21 | S$2,351,975 | S$1,172,808 |
| 22 | S$2,497,917 | S$1,219,720 |
| 23 | S$2,650,558 | S$1,268,509 |
| 24 | S$2,810,193 | S$1,319,249 |
| 25 | S$2,977,130 | S$1,372,019 |
| 26 | S$3,151,658 | S$1,426,900 |
| 27 | S$3,333,957 | S$1,483,976 |
| 28 | S$3,524,363 | S$1,543,335 |
| 29 | S$3,723,223 | S$1,605,069 |
| 30 | S$3,930,904 | S$1,669,271 |
Owning in year 1, per month
| Item | Per month |
|---|---|
| Mortgage payment | S$4,504 |
| Interest, part of the payment (a cost) | S$2,413 |
| Principal, part of the payment (saving: it lowers the loan) | S$2,091 |
| Upkeep | S$450 |
| Property tax (owner-occupied) | S$133 |
| Return the cash at the start could have earned | S$1,409 |
| Cost of owning, principal left out | S$4,405 |
| Rent for a like home | S$4,000 |
| Home price growth in year 1, if it grows as set | S$3,750 |
Year by year
| Year | Home value | Loan left | Selling costs | SSD | Owning, net | Renting, net | Owning minus renting |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | S$1,545,000 | S$1,099,907 | S$30,900 | S$247,200 | S$166,993 | S$452,787 | -S$285,794 |
| 2 | S$1,591,350 | S$1,074,153 | S$31,827 | S$190,962 | S$294,408 | S$482,914 | -S$188,506 |
| 3 | S$1,639,091 | S$1,050,044 | S$32,782 | S$131,127 | S$425,137 | S$517,134 | -S$91,997 |
| 4 | S$1,688,263 | S$1,025,153 | S$33,765 | S$67,530 | S$561,815 | S$551,437 | S$10,378 |
| 5 | S$1,738,911 | S$999,454 | S$34,778 | S$0 | S$704,679 | S$585,787 | S$118,892 |
| 6 | S$1,791,078 | S$972,920 | S$35,822 | S$0 | S$782,337 | S$620,145 | S$162,192 |
| 7 | S$1,844,811 | S$945,524 | S$36,896 | S$0 | S$862,391 | S$654,469 | S$207,922 |
| 8 | S$1,900,155 | S$917,238 | S$38,003 | S$0 | S$944,914 | S$688,714 | S$256,200 |
| 9 | S$1,957,160 | S$888,034 | S$39,143 | S$0 | S$1,029,982 | S$722,832 | S$307,150 |
| 10 | S$2,015,875 | S$857,882 | S$40,317 | S$0 | S$1,117,675 | S$756,772 | S$360,903 |
| 11 | S$2,076,351 | S$826,751 | S$41,527 | S$0 | S$1,208,073 | S$790,480 | S$417,593 |
| 12 | S$2,138,641 | S$794,608 | S$42,773 | S$0 | S$1,301,260 | S$823,896 | S$477,364 |
| 13 | S$2,202,801 | S$761,422 | S$44,056 | S$0 | S$1,397,322 | S$856,959 | S$540,363 |
| 14 | S$2,268,885 | S$727,158 | S$45,378 | S$0 | S$1,497,983 | S$891,238 | S$606,746 |
| 15 | S$2,336,951 | S$691,782 | S$46,739 | S$0 | S$1,603,561 | S$926,887 | S$676,674 |
| 16 | S$2,407,060 | S$655,257 | S$48,141 | S$0 | S$1,714,279 | S$963,963 | S$750,316 |
| 17 | S$2,479,271 | S$617,545 | S$49,585 | S$0 | S$1,830,289 | S$1,002,521 | S$827,768 |
| 18 | S$2,553,650 | S$578,609 | S$51,073 | S$0 | S$1,951,821 | S$1,042,622 | S$909,199 |
| 19 | S$2,630,259 | S$538,409 | S$52,605 | S$0 | S$2,079,122 | S$1,084,327 | S$994,795 |
| 20 | S$2,709,167 | S$496,903 | S$54,183 | S$0 | S$2,212,451 | S$1,127,700 | S$1,084,751 |
| 21 | S$2,790,442 | S$454,049 | S$55,809 | S$0 | S$2,351,975 | S$1,172,808 | S$1,179,167 |
| 22 | S$2,874,155 | S$409,804 | S$57,483 | S$0 | S$2,497,917 | S$1,219,720 | S$1,278,196 |
| 23 | S$2,960,380 | S$364,122 | S$59,208 | S$0 | S$2,650,558 | S$1,268,509 | S$1,382,049 |
| 24 | S$3,049,191 | S$316,956 | S$60,984 | S$0 | S$2,810,193 | S$1,319,249 | S$1,490,944 |
| 25 | S$3,140,667 | S$268,259 | S$62,813 | S$0 | S$2,977,130 | S$1,372,019 | S$1,605,111 |
| 26 | S$3,234,887 | S$217,980 | S$64,698 | S$0 | S$3,151,658 | S$1,426,900 | S$1,724,758 |
| 27 | S$3,331,934 | S$166,069 | S$66,639 | S$0 | S$3,333,957 | S$1,483,976 | S$1,849,981 |
| 28 | S$3,431,892 | S$112,472 | S$68,638 | S$0 | S$3,524,363 | S$1,543,335 | S$1,981,027 |
| 29 | S$3,534,848 | S$57,135 | S$70,697 | S$0 | S$3,723,223 | S$1,605,069 | S$2,118,155 |
| 30 | S$3,640,894 | S$0 | S$72,818 | S$0 | S$3,930,904 | S$1,669,271 | S$2,261,633 |
Red rows: renting leaves more.
Assumptions and rules used
These are the values behind every number on this page. They are always shown.
- Rules applied as at
- 19 Oct 2026
- Loan
- S$1,125,000 over 30 years, 2.60% for 2 years, then 3.20%
- Home price and rent growth
- 3.00% and 3.00% a year
- Return on invested money
- 4.00% a year, same for both sides
- Annual value for property tax
- 1 x a year of rent
- Selling costs
- 2.00% of the sale price
Rules used
- bsd.residential, rule dated 15 Feb 2023: 1/2/3/4/5/6% bands; 5% on S$1.5m to S$3m and 6% above S$3m. Source
- property-tax.residential-owner-occupied, rule dated 1 Jan 2025: Owner-occupied: 0% on the first S$12,000, rising to 32% above S$140,000, in 8 slices. Source
- ssd.residential, rule dated 4 Jul 2025: Holding period back to 4 years; rates up 4 pp to 16% / 12% / 8% / 4%. Source
- cpf.oa-interest, rule dated 1 Jan 2008: The OA earns 2.5% a year, the legislated minimum, because the bank-rate peg is far below the floor. Source
Limits of this tool
- Both households have the same housing budget. Each month, whoever spends less on housing invests the difference at the return above.
- The home is assumed to be a first home that you live in, so there is no ABSD and the owner-occupied property tax rates apply. Property tax uses the rates in force on 1 Jan of this year for every year shown.
- SSD is taken from the rule for purchases on or after the date it started; a sale on the anniversary counts in the earlier band. CPF is not modelled: money from CPF is treated as cash.
- Growth, rent, rate and return figures are your assumptions. Change them and the break-even year moves, sometimes by many years.
Rule files last checked 4 Oct 2026.
Not financial advice; check current rules with IRAS and MAS. Results are estimates from the inputs and the dated rules shown.